I've been thinking about the whole Rick Warren controversy a lot in the last few days.
I'm angry. I'm surprised. And I'm hurt.
I'm angry at Barack Obama. I get that he's a politician, and never in the campaign did he really advocate for the LGBT community. His description of himself as a "fierce advocate" for gay & lesbian equality is mind blowing, though. One is not a "fierce advocate" for equality while not backing equal rights - as is the case with Mr. Obama and marriage equality.
I'm surprised that his staff and campaign are so tone deaf as to think that a leading evangelical from California who fought to take away our right to marry and compared our relationships to incest and pedophilia should be given such a leading role at his inauguration. And to say it's okay because they also invited a gay band is just insulting.
But what gets me the most has been the reaction of some of my straight friends. With the wonderful world of Facebook, I am able to keep up with my friends, what they're doing, and - with their updates ("Maine Gay is...") - know what they're thinking.
So when a good friend of mine posted "xxx is sad that the gay community is whining about Rick Warren. They have to accept that there are people with different views on social issues.", I was speechless - and hurt.
And he hasn't been the only one. I've heard variances of "America isn't ready for gay marriage" to "it's just a prayer" to "he has to be open on social issues" from a number of straight people.
And that lead me to this conclusion. Some of my best friends don't see me as equal to them.
I've actually, deep down, always kind of known this. I have sensed, whether when dating someone or when I was in a long term relationship, that it's seen by some of my friends as "cute". But not really a relationship. Not like theirs.
But, with this issue, it really just hit me in the face that, as Red so eloquently said in a comment on his previous post, to many people gay is something we do, not who we are.
I have many thoughts and feeling going through me with this realization, some of which I won't say because I know I don't mean them. But in short:
We are not a "social issue" or a "viewpoint". We are fully equal human beings, and we expect and deserve to be treated with the respect and dignity that entails.
We are not a "cause". Please don't use us as a way to make yourself feel good about how progressive you are. In the end, its just demeaning to everyone involved.
We are tired of being used. "Progressive" politicians take our money, our time, our expertise, and our votes, but there is little consequence when they turn away after the election. Meanwhile we are repeatedly told that its for "the greater good". And I get that to some extent, in the big picture way. But I've got to tell you, when I got an appeal for more money from Obama this week, it infuriated me. You know what? Go raise it at Saddleback Church. I'm done for a while.
Let me be clear - I'm not "re-evaluating my friendships" with my straight friends. I am, though, seeing some of them in a new light.
By talking about it, though, I'm hoping to work through it. And maybe - just maybe - get some of them to take a look at how they really view me and my community.
And in the end, that might just lead us all to a better place.
Saturday, December 20, 2008
Some Of My Best Friends
File under:
Diversity and Social Justice,
Maine Gay,
politically motivated
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
5 whoop-whoop(s):
About a year ago, seemingly out of nowhere, one of the adoptive lesbian moms said, "You know what I hate about straight people?" I steeled myself and said, "Um ... what?" She replied, "Most straight people, at their core, thing they're better than we are just because they're straight."
And I said, "you're right, most of them probably do." But at the same time, most white people think they're better than people of color, most Christians think they're better than Jews, and most men think they're better than women. It's the way privilege works.
I go back and forth on the Warren thing. When I think back to election night, I can still tap into the joy I felt to finally have backed a winner - I've gotten over the shock of the Warren thing, and now I'm just baffled. Did Obama think we wouldn't be upset? Did he believe that the evangelicals would come his way after throwing them such a tiny bone? Did he think it was a win-win? Because every day it looks more like a lose-lose.
I'm sorry that your straight friends are disappointing you - all of my straight folks have either been silent on the issue or completely supportive. Meanwhile, I'm launching a campaign to get every gay person and straight ally on the Mall on Jan. 20 to hum the tune to "I Am What I Am" throughout Warren's entire invocation. Nothing that will disrupt Barack's big day, but loud enough to be heard. Unfortunately, nobody but me thinks it's a great idea. Oh well.
I like to say that I'm straight but not narrow...I'm so pissed at our golden boy that given the opportunity I'd bip him right up side his head...I'm soo angry over this..what a fecking slap in the face to the gay community...horrible, just horrible.
Red - I'm not really disappointed, I'm simply going through the shock of realization. And I certainly don't want to give the impression that all or even a majority of my straight friends haven't been supportive. I just feel like we put so much into the fight and are expected to "be patient" all too often.
Yellowdog - You are a rock star. I love how outspoken you are, not just on my rights but in general. Which is why so many of us make a regular pilgramage to your blog. Tell it like you see it, girl. On that note, I'm never surprised to hear someone that doesn't think I'm their equal say so. I'm just surprised that some people I thought saw me as an equal don't really. That hurts more - a lot more.
Good post. I've been baffled, too. I tell myself that maybe he's a bigger person than I, that he's looking at the bigger picture, trying to bring people together after the extreme Bush-Reagan-Bush polarization we've come to.
But it sounds lame. Like I'm looking for excuses, because I so want him to live up to all my expectations.
The Bohemian (my eldest daughter) didn't vote for Obama, because "he's not progressive enough". In the interest of full disclosure, she is a student in DC, which goes overwhelmingly Dem in any election, so she knew she could lodge a protest vote without effectively throwing it to McCain. She voted for Cynthia McKinney. We went
round and round about this before the election -- I just couldn't believe, that she, a progressive, politically and socially aware, African American young woman, would not vote for Barack Obama in this historic election -- NOT because she wanted to vote for McCain, but because she felt a vote for Obama was "selling out". One of her main reasons was that he did not support gay marriage, or support the LGBT community to the extent she felt a President should. She told me she wasn't willing to settle for that kind of lukewarm support.
Anyway, as much as I agreed with her sentiment, I guess age has taught me something about idealism v. what you can realistically accomplish. I am still largely supportive of Obama, but don't know what to make about this Pastor thing. I felt really let down.
And it sure was hard to watch my daughter shake her head at me this week, with a disgusted, "told you." I had no answer.
What's wrong with incest and paedophilia? You gays would be much happier with yourselves (and wouldn't take out all your insecurities on other people) if you weren't so intolerant and hypocritical.
Post a Comment